Early Fishing Lures Creek Chub, Heddon, Paw Paw, South Bend, Shakespeare Lures & MORE
Paw Paw Meadow Brook Underwater Minnow in the Box Rainbow Finish
Paw Paw Meadow Brook Underwater Minnow in the Box Rainbow Finish
$110.00$80.00
Shakespeare Kazoo Wobbler Minnow in Yellow Perch
Shakespeare Kazoo Wobbler Minnow in Yellow Perch
$225.00
Creek Chub Mouse in Pearl "Tough Little Mouse"
Creek Chub Mouse in Pearl "Tough Little Mouse"
$125.00$85.00
Mitchell 300 Fishing Reel in the Box with Papers + Spare Spool
Mitchell 300 Fishing Reel in the Box with Papers + Spare Spool
$65.00$45.00
Montague Senate 250 Yard Model German Silver
Montague Senate 250 Yard Model German Silver
$85.00$80.00
Mitchell 330 Fishing Reel Excellent Condition
Mitchell 330 Fishing Reel Excellent Condition
$45.00$35.00
Heddon Lucky 13 Plastic Fishing Lure in Red Head Frog Scale
Heddon Lucky 13 Plastic Fishing Lure in Red Head Frog Scale
$35.00$30.00
J.T. Buel Metal #1 Spinner Bait with Feathered Treble Hook
J.T. Buel Metal #1 Spinner Bait with Feathered Treble Hook
$50.00$42.00
Creek Chub 2600 F Frog Pikie Minnow New Old Stock Fishing Lure
Creek Chub 2600 F Frog Pikie Minnow New Old Stock Fishing Lure
$12.00$10.00
South Bend Collector's B.A.S.S. Series Bass Oreno Fishing Lure NEW!
South Bend Collector's B.A.S.S. Series Bass Oreno Fishing Lure NEW!
$35.00$30.00
Shur Strike Baby Bass Oreno Type in CRISP BOX!
Shur Strike Baby Bass Oreno Type in CRISP BOX!
$75.00$50.00
Shur Strike by Creek Chub Injured Minnow EX IN BOX Perch Finish!
Shur Strike by Creek Chub Injured Minnow EX IN BOX Perch Finish!
$130.00$95.00
Creek Chub Fly Rod Fishing Lure Box
Creek Chub Fly Rod Fishing Lure Box
$30.00$20.00
Creek Chub 1521 Day N Night Luminous Injured Minnow Fishing Lure
Creek Chub 1521 Day N Night Luminous Injured Minnow Fishing Lure
$110.00$70.00
Nice Rare Green Shur Strike Lure Box ONLY
Nice Rare Green Shur Strike Lure Box ONLY
$60.00$30.00
Creek Chub 1518 Injured Minnow Fishing Lure NIB + Military Stencil
Creek Chub 1518 Injured Minnow Fishing Lure NIB + Military Stencil
$75.00$65.00
New Creek Chub 2200 Midget Pikie Minnow Fishing Lure
New Creek Chub 2200 Midget Pikie Minnow Fishing Lure
$50.00
Paw Paw Unknown Name Fishing Lure Spinner Bait
Paw Paw Unknown Name Fishing Lure Spinner Bait
$45.00
Baby Phantom Aluminum Float with Bucktail Circa 1897
Baby Phantom Aluminum Float with Bucktail Circa 1897
$130.00$90.00
Best O Luck Underwater Minnow South Bend Fishing Lure
Best O Luck Underwater Minnow South Bend Fishing Lure
$65.00$45.00
South Bend 956 P Pike Oreno OBSOLETE stamp with Catalog
South Bend 956 P Pike Oreno OBSOLETE stamp with Catalog
$45.00$42.00
Creek Chub Jointed SNOOK 5501 Perch New in the Box!
Creek Chub Jointed SNOOK 5501 Perch New in the Box!
$35.00
Heddon 740 Wood Punkinseed in Shad Fishing Lure
Heddon 740 Wood Punkinseed in Shad Fishing Lure
$135.00$125.00
Creek Chub Jointed Darter FROG NEW! in Box + Papers
Creek Chub Jointed Darter FROG NEW! in Box + Papers
$45.00
Rush Tango Victory Finish Wood Fishing Lure
Rush Tango Victory Finish Wood Fishing Lure
$45.00
Shakespeare GOLDFISH Sea Witch in NEW CONDITION! Beautiful Bait!
Shakespeare GOLDFISH Sea Witch in NEW CONDITION! Beautiful Bait!
$110.00$70.00
Creek Chub Baby Injured Minnow 1605 Plastic NEW in the BOX with PAPERS!
Creek Chub Baby Injured Minnow 1605 Plastic NEW in the BOX with PAPERS!
$45.00$30.00
Creek Chub 1618 Silver Flash BABY INJURED MINNOW with Painted Eyes NIB!
Creek Chub 1618 Silver Flash BABY INJURED MINNOW with Painted Eyes NIB!
$40.00$35.00
Larger Size Pflueger Wizard in Frog Spot
Larger Size Pflueger Wizard in Frog Spot
$115.00$95.00
Scarce PEARL 738 Creek Chub Pikie Minnow NEW IN BOX!
Scarce PEARL 738 Creek Chub Pikie Minnow NEW IN BOX!
$295.00$225.00
Pair of Creek Chub BOXES ONLY 708 Pikie Lure in Rainbow No Tops
Pair of Creek Chub BOXES ONLY 708 Pikie Lure in Rainbow No Tops
$10.00
Fred Arbogast 3/8 OZ. Jitterbug NEW in RARE BUBBLE PACK
Fred Arbogast 3/8 OZ. Jitterbug NEW in RARE BUBBLE PACK
$35.00$30.00
Fred Arbogast 5/8 OZ. Jitterbug NEW in RARE BUBBLE PACK
Fred Arbogast 5/8 OZ. Jitterbug NEW in RARE BUBBLE PACK
$45.00$32.00
Creek Chub 1621 Baby Injured Minnow LUMINOUS Day N Night RARE!
Creek Chub 1621 Baby Injured Minnow LUMINOUS Day N Night RARE!
$250.00$170.00
Best O Luck by South Bend Lure New in the Box 931 RH
Best O Luck by South Bend Lure New in the Box 931 RH
$45.00$35.00
Shur Strike Rainbow River Runt Fishing Lure
Shur Strike Rainbow River Runt Fishing Lure
$35.00$25.00
Heddon 210 Series Wood Fishing Lure
Heddon 210 Series Wood Fishing Lure
$30.00$25.00
Creek Chub Midget Darter 8013 ALL BLACK EX+ Fishing Lure
Creek Chub Midget Darter 8013 ALL BLACK EX+ Fishing Lure
$30.00$25.00
Eger Stump Knocker Midget Darter Type Fishing Lure UNFISHED IN BOX
Eger Stump Knocker Midget Darter Type Fishing Lure UNFISHED IN BOX
$35.00$20.00
Heddon Spook Super Dowagiac 9100 Fishing Lure with Toilet Seat HDWR Glass Eyes
Heddon Spook Super Dowagiac 9100 Fishing Lure with Toilet Seat HDWR Glass Eyes
$65.00$50.00
Whopper Stopper Jointed Fishing Lure 4" model
Whopper Stopper Jointed Fishing Lure 4" model
$30.00$20.00
Paw Paw Popper 2200 NICE FROG Fishing Lure
Paw Paw Popper 2200 NICE FROG Fishing Lure
$60.00$50.00
Shur Strike River Runt Glass Eyes with Black Eye Shadow!
Shur Strike River Runt Glass Eyes with Black Eye Shadow!
$35.00$32.00
Creek Chub Beetle 3852 Fishing Lure Pretty Clean
Creek Chub Beetle 3852 Fishing Lure Pretty Clean
$175.00$155.00
Creek Chub Darter Frog EX in Correct Box
Creek Chub Darter Frog EX in Correct Box
$25.00
Rush Tango New in the Box with Rare Papers
Rush Tango New in the Box with Rare Papers
$110.00$95.00
Pflueger FOUR BROTHERS Box & Spinner Lure NEW! Rare Combo
Pflueger FOUR BROTHERS Box & Spinner Lure NEW! Rare Combo
$185.00$105.00
Creek Chub Beetle 3850 EX with Military Stencil NICE!
Creek Chub Beetle 3850 EX with Military Stencil NICE!
$165.00$100.00